Cilia in autophagy and cancer
Cilia volume 5, Article number: 4 (2015)
Cancer cells are distinguished from normal cells by increased proliferation and metabolism, loss of polarity control, and the potential to invade other tissues of the body. As hubs of signaling transduction, primary cilia have been linked to diverse developmental and degenerative disorders. Interestingly, loss of cilia has been observed in multiple malignant tumors, suggesting a potential suppressive role of cilia in cancer development. More recently, emerging studies began to unveil the bidirectional interaction of cilia and autophagy, a basic cellular clearance and recycling mechanism to regulate cell homeostasis. Here, we summarize the interplay between cilia and autophagy and discuss the roles of cilia in both autophagy and cancer.
Cilia/flagella are eukaryotic cell organelles protruding from cell surface into environment. Most vertebrate cells assemble a single primary cilium, when they exit from the cell cycle into differentiated or quiescent status . This ~5 μm tall, microtubule-based protrusion is essential for multiple signaling transductions [2, 3]. Autophagy is a destructive cellular process to degrade disordered cell organelles and protein aggregates, and maintain cellular homeostasis. More recently, cilia are attracting interests as structures having bidirectional interaction with autophagy. This review will discuss the relationship between cilia and autophagy and emphasize the function of cilia in cancer development.
The connections between cilia and cancer
Primary cilium possesses an axoneme consisting of nine doublet microtubules, which is surrounded by a specialized membrane . In interphase, cilium biogenesis is initiated by the attachment of a Golgi-derived membrane vesicle on the distal end of mother centriole [5, 6]. Subsequently, the nucleated axoneme buds from mother centriole and bends the cell membrane to form the structure [5, 6]. Considering that centrosomes direct spindle formation in mitosis, cilia must be disassembled before mitosis to liberate the captive centriole and to promote the formation of spindle [7–10]. The presence of cilia can suppress abnormal cell growth by restricting cell cycle (Fig. 1). Although the ciliary membrane is continuous with cell membrane, the lipid and protein compositions of ciliary membrane are different from cell membrane compositions [11–15]. The specialized ciliary membrane makes cilia capable of transducing multiple cellular signaling [2, 16–21].
Since primary cilia have the ability to influence cell cycle and modulate cilia-related signaling transduction, dysfunction of cilia has long been proposed as a prerequisite step of cancer development [7, 22]. In contrast to normal cells, cilia are lost in multiple cancer types . Clinical data also show that cilia formation is compromised in multiple human cancers including breast cancer, cholangiocarcinoma, melanoma, pancreatic cancer, prostate cancer, and renal cell carcinoma [17, 22–30]. These observations suggest that cilia play a suppressive role in cancer development. Although defective cilia and cancer are always associated, a direct role of cilia in tumorigenesis is still elusive.
The negative correlation between cilia and cell cycle has been discovered for many decades. The studies in Snell’s group provided the first molecular link between cilia disassembly and cell cycle progression [7, 31]. They found that the disassembly of Chlamydomonas cilia requires protein CALK, a member of Aurora kinase family, which promotes cell cycle . In 2007, Golemis’s group optimized a system to study the mechanisms of cilia disassembly . Briefly, cells were treated by serum starvation to induce cilia formation. Serum was added into the medium to trigger cilia disassembly and cell cycle re-entry. Like the observation in Chlamydomonas, they found that mammalian cells also shorten their cilia through Aurora kinase-dependent pathway. Upon serum stimulation, HEF1 activated Aurora A, which phosphorylated HDAC6 to promote cilia disassembly during cell cycle re-entry [32, 33]. According to these findings, a straightforward question will be whether cell cycle progression is blocked with defective cilia disassembly? Tsiokas and colleagues found that knockdown of Nde1, a mother centriole-localized protein, led to elongated cilia in mammalian cells . Interestingly, G0 cells with longer cilia by depletion of Nde1 delayed cell cycle re-entry after serum addition. To confirm the delayed re-entry was caused by cilia, the group co-knockdown Nde1 with either Ift88 or Ift20, two essential genes for ciliogenesis, and found that the inhibitory effect was reversed . Concomitantly, Sung’s group showed that Tctex-1 localizes to transition zone after phosphorylation at Thr94, where it promotes cilia disassembly before S-phase entry . Consistently, depletion of Tctex-1 resulted in delayed cilia disassembly along with delayed cell cycle re-entry in ciliated cells, but not in non-ciliated cells . Both of the studies indicate a suppressive role of cilia in cell cycle progression (Fig. 1), raising the possibility that loss of cilia promotes unrestricted cell cycle progression in cancer cells.
The other important function of primary cilium is its ability to regulate multiple signaling pathways, the dysfunctions of which are associated with a number of cancers . As a cilia-dependent pathway (Fig. 2a), Sonic Hedgehog (Shh) signaling has important functions in guiding embryonic development by regulating cell differentiation and proliferation [20, 36–39]. In the absence of Shh ligand, membrane proteins Patched and Gpr161 are localized to cilia. On the other hand, the most majority of Smoothened is excluded from cilia, though a basal level of protein is thought to be traffic through cilia as well [37, 39]. Shh transcriptional factors Gli2 and Gli3 are cleaved to Gli2R and Gli3R repressor forms and inhibit Shh downstream transcriptions . Upon the Shh ligand binding, Patched and Gpr161 are moved out from cilia, but Smoothened is accumulated in cilia. Consequently, the stabilized Gli2 and Gli3 can be activated as Gli2A and Gli3A, which trigger the transcription of Gli1 and other Shh target genes [39, 40]. In several types of cancers, the abnormal activations of Shh are observed [22, 41–43]. For instance, dysregulated activation of Shh contributes to basal cell carcinoma and medulloblastoma development [41, 43]. It is interesting that primary cilia are either positive or negative regulators of Shh-related oncogenesis, depending on the initiating oncogenic mutations [41, 43]. Wnt signaling is critical to animal development and homeostasis . Upregulation of Wnt signaling has also been linked to tumorigenesis [22, 42, 44]. Although the functions of cilia in Wnt signaling are still controversial, it seems that both canonical and non-canonical Wnt signaling can be regulated by cilia (Fig. 2b, c). Down regulation or loss of ciliary proteins, including BBS1, BBS4, Kif3a, IFT88, and OFD1, leads to accumulation of β-catenin, which subsequently increases the transcription of Wnt target genes in Zebrafish embryos and mouse cells and embryos [21, 44, 45]. Interestingly, Ift88, Ift172, and Kif3a mutant mice, which also lack functional primary cilia, failed to show any phenotype caused by upregulated Wnt signaling . Considering that Wnt signaling is strictly regulated in specific developmental stage and tissue, these results may still reflect the ability of cilia to regulate Wnt signaling. In contrast to canonical Wnt, non-canonical signaling is β-catenin independent and involved in the regulation of cell polarity [47–49]. Cystic diseases are well-established models of human diseases caused by dysfunctional cilia. Similar with tumor cells, a typical symptom of cystic organs is a loss of cell polarity [17, 50–52]. Consistent with these observations, planar cell polarity (PCP) mutant phenotypes, including open eyelids and disorganized stereocilia, are found in Bbs1, Bbs4, and Bbs6 defective mice . Loss of two cilia-related proteins, Ivn/NPHP2 and OFD1, also leads to PCP-regulated convergent extension defects in vertebrates [48, 54]. All of these studies demonstrated that cilia are capable of regulating both canonical and non-canonical Wnt signaling [18, 44, 46, 55–57].
Including Shh and Wnt, the list of cilia-related signalings is growing fast. TGF-beta, Hippo, and notch signaling are also connected with cilia [17, 58–61]. In addition to the function of receiving and transducing signaling, recent studies in Chlamydomonas showed cilia can also release signaling active vesicles and act as signaling transmitting organelles to regulate the behavior of other cells [62–64]. All these studies show a strong link between cilia and cancer development. However, if and how cilia function in tumorigenesis remains unclear. Tumors are highly heterogeneous tissues and consisted of different cell types, including tumors cells and tumor-associated fibroblasts, endothelial cells, and immune cells [65–69]. These cells and extra-cellular matrix constitute tumor stroma [66, 69, 70]. Functioning as sensing organelles, loss of cilia may alter the signaling network and cell–cell communications inside tumor stroma. Involved in multiple signaling, the function of cilia in tumorigenesis will be far more complex than it appears now and will not be limited to the cell cycle regulation and polarity control. If and how cilia contribute to cancer development remains an important question to be addressed.
The bidirectional interplay between cilia and autophagy
Autophagy has essential functions in multiple physiological processes . The relationship of cilia and autophagy has been missing for a long period. A set of recent studies established the relationship of cilia and autophagy (Fig. 3) [72–74]. In contrast to cells in vivo, most in vitro cultured cells do not express cilia. Early studies showed that serum withdrawal leads to cell cycle exit and induces ciliogenesis. Interestingly, serum starvation can also trigger autophagy. The most natural question to ask is if these two concurrent events are related? Tang and colleagues demonstrated that OFD1, a ciliopathy protein, was degraded by autophagy to promote cilia formation upon serum starvation [72, 75]. OFD1 is localized to two cilia-related subcellular structures, distal end of centrioles and centriolar satellites [72, 76–78]. The centriolar OFD1 is thought to maintain centriolar length and integrity, which is required for cilia formation . However, the function of satellite pool was unclear. Tang showed that autophagy largely eliminated the satellite OFD1 but not centriolar OFD1. Inhibition of autophagy attenuated satellite OFD1 degradation and led to lower ciliogenesis rate and shorter cilia. Consistently, depletion of OFD1 by RNA interference dramatically increased cilia formation in murine embryonic cells and restored ciliogenesis in MCF7 cells, a breast cancer cell line originally lacking cilia . All these data demonstrated a suppressive role of satellite OFD1 in cilia formation and suggested a positive role of autophagy in ciliogenesis. In contrast to stimulated autophagy, Cuervo’s group showed that basal level autophagy acts as a negative regulator for ciliogenesis by degrading IFT20, ciliary essential protein . The switch of basal autophagy and stimulated autophagy may potentiate autophagy positively or negatively controlling cilia formation in response to environmental changes . However, a surprising aspect in these two studies is that the ratio of ciliated cells to ciliary length in ATG5−/− autophagy-defective MEF cells are quite different [72, 74]. Given that the confluence of cells has strong influence on cilia formation, one possible explanation of the observations might be attributed to the different status of cell density in these two studies. MTOR is a known negative regulator of autophagy . Wang et al. showed that MTOR activity is upregulated in cilia-suppressed cells, also suggesting that lower autophagy level is associated with attenuated cilia formation . Consistent with the observation, they also showed that upregulating autophagy activity prompted cilia elongation and downregulating autophagy activity led to shortened cilia in kidney cells . Taken together; these studies demonstrated that autophagy can serve as a dual-role regulator of ciliogenesis by alternatively eliminating ciliary essential protein(s) or its suppressive protein(s) [75, 79]. Understanding of the mechanisms that controls the autophagy switch to turn on/off of cilia formation will be an important question for future studies.
Despite the function of autophagy in ciliogenesis, cilia and cilia-related Shh signaling are potential regulators of autophagy. Several components of autophagic machinery localize around ciliary or periciliary region [74, 79]. ATG16L, AMBRA1, LC3, GABARAP, and VPS15 staining showed discrete puncta along cilia [74, 79]. ATG14, VPS34, ATG7, and ATG5 are found at the basal body region [74, 79]. Regarding the vesicular activity of ciliary pocket, the presence of autophagic initiating molecules around cilia suggests ciliary area as a possible novel origin of autophagosome formation to activate autophagy. Consistently, lower autophagy activity is observed in IFT20 knockdown MEF cells and IFT88 knockout kidney epithelial cells, both of which have defects in ciliogenesis [74, 79]. Interestingly, the activation of Shh rescued the defective autophagy flux, indicating that cilia upregulate autophagy through cilia-dependent Shh signaling [74, 79]. In another study, cilia-suppressed cells also showed repressed autophagy, which might be resulted from enhanced MTOR activity . In ciliated neuron and smooth muscle cells, autophagy activation was also observed after the upregulation of Shh by its ligand binding [82, 83]. One argument against the positive role of cilia in promoting autophagy comes from the studies of Pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma (PDAC). PDAC are malignant tumors with high-level autophagy . However, cilia are absent in human and mouse PDAC tissues compared to highly ciliated normal tissues . In other word, cilia loss fails to downregulate autophagy in these malignant cells. Although cilia and cilia-dependent Shh have emerged as possible regulators of autophagy, more insightful mechanisms of the regulating system remain to be elucidated.
Does the crosstalk between cilia and autophagy influence cancer development?
The first link between autophagy and cancer is from the studies of Beclin 1, an essential protein for autophagy initiation [85, 86]. Unlike other tumor suppressors, Beclin 1 is characterized as a haploid-insufficient tumor suppressor gene, monoallelic mutations of which lead to defective function [85, 86]. Interestingly, only premalignant tumors, but not malignant tumors, are observed in autophagy-deficient mice by knockout of atg5 or atg7, two autophagy essential genes, suggesting a suppressive role of autophagy in cell transformation . In contrast to the function of autophagy in transformation, high level of autophagy is required in malignant tumors, including PDAC and non-small cell lung cancer, to maintain the high level of metabolism [84, 88, 89]. These data suggest a dual role of autophagy in cancer development (Fig. 3). One possible explanation is that autophagy plays different roles in cell transformation and transformed cell progression. At the early stage of cancer development, autophagy can degrade harmful factors, including aggregated proteins and aged mitochondria, to prevent cells from accumulating genomic mutations [89–92]. After cancer cell transformation, autophagy can provide substrates for high-level metabolism and prevent toxic product accumulation, both of which promote cancer survival and proliferation [89, 92]. Additionally, autophagy may also have function inside tumor stroma via the altered secretory products and surface characters [93–98]. Emerging studies suggested that autophagy contributes to starvation and hypoxia-evoked angiogenesis, which promotes tumor stroma accessing more nutrients [99–101]. Activated autophagy in cancer-associated fibroblasts provides more metabolic products to ‘feed’ high proliferative cancer cells with enhanced energy demands [102–105]. Regarding immunity changes in tumor stroma are important for cancer development, studies to demonstrate whether and how autophagy affects immunosurveillance will give more insightful information of autophagy and tumorigenesis .
As discussed above, cilia can restrict mitosis and inhibit abnormal cell proliferation [7, 17, 22]. In this way, theoretically, cilia serve as negative regulator of cancer development by providing additional checkpoint of cell cycle progression.
In ciliated cells, the presence of cilia might positively regulate autophagy, preventing metabolic waste accumulation and constitutive cellular damage, which is a potent factor in inducing cancer development [74, 92]. However, in malignant cells, why the loss of cilia and upregulated autophagy are associated together is still poorly understood. Reversely, autophagy has dual roles in ciliogenesis by degrading essential or suppressive cilia-related proteins. If autophagy plays a role in cancer through cilia, how cells modulate the switch to turn on/off cilia expression will be an important point to be addressed. Although the interplay between cilia and autophagy has emerged, recent studies may have just begun to touch a small tip of a giant iceberg. Future studies will hopefully provide more evidences to reveal the complicated connections between cilia and autophagy.
The list of cilia’s functions is growing fast. As discussed above, cilia can restrict mitosis and inhibit abnormal cell proliferation [7, 17, 22]. In this way, theoretically, cilia serve as negative regulator of cancer development by providing additional checkpoint of cell cycle progression. Interestingly, the bidirectional interplay between cilia and autophagy is emerging as a new field for future studies. Autophagy selectively turns on/off cilia formation by alternatively degrading ciliary essential protein, IFT20, or suppressive protein, OFD1. The mechanisms modulating this switch are still unknown. Involved in autophagy initiation, cilia enhance autophagy flux through cilia-related Shh. Whether and how other cilia-related signaling(s) participate(s) autophagy regulation remains unclear. Given the broad functions of cilia and autophagy in the regulation of cell proliferation and metabolism, discovery of drugs specifically targeting these two regulators will provide a wide therapeutic approach for cancer and other diseases.
Sonic Hedgehog signaling
oral-facial-digital syndrome 1
planar cell polarity
pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma
Wheatley DN, Wang AM, Strugnell GE. Expression of primary cilia in mammalian cells. Cell Biol Int. 1996;20(1):73–81.
Schou KB, Pedersen LB, Christensen ST. Ins and outs of GPCR signaling in primary cilia. EMBO Rep. 2015;16(9):1099–113.
Pan J, Wang Q, Snell WJ. Cilium-generated signaling and cilia-related disorders. Lab Invest. 2005;85(4):452–63.
Rosenbaum JL, Witman GB. Intraflagellar transport. Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol. 2002;3(11):813–25.
Sorokin S. Centrioles and the formation of rudimentary cilia by fibroblasts and smooth muscle cells. J Cell Biol. 1962;15:363–77.
Garcia-Gonzalo FR, Reiter JF. Scoring a backstage pass: mechanisms of ciliogenesis and ciliary access. J Cell Biol. 2012;197(6):697–709.
Pan J, Snell W. The primary cilium: keeper of the key to cell division. Cell. 2007;129(7):1255–7.
Tucker RW, Scher CD, Stiles CD. Centriole deciliation associated with the early response of 3T3 cells to growth factors but not to SV40. Cell. 1979;18(4):1065–72.
Tucker RW, Pardee AB, Fujiwara K. Centriole ciliation is related to quiescence and DNA synthesis in 3T3 cells. Cell. 1979;17(3):527–35.
Rieder CL, Jensen CG, Jensen LC. The resorption of primary cilia during mitosis in a vertebrate (PtK1) cell line. J Ultrastruct Res. 1979;68(2):173–85.
Nakatsu F. A Phosphoinositide Code for Primary Cilia. Dev Cell. 2015;34(4):379–80.
Breslow DK, Nachury MV. Analysis of soluble protein entry into primary cilia using semipermeabilized cells. Methods Cell Biol. 2015;127:203–21.
Nachury MV. How do cilia organize signalling cascades? Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci. 2014;369(1650):20130465. doi:10.1098/rstb.2013.0465.
Breslow DK, Nachury MV. Primary cilia: how to keep the riff-raff in the plasma membrane. Curr Biol. 2011;21(11):R434–6.
Jin H, White SR, Shida T, Schulz S, Aguiar M, Gygi SP, Bazan JF, Nachury MV. The conserved Bardet-Biedl syndrome proteins assemble a coat that traffics membrane proteins to cilia. Cell. 2010;141(7):1208–19.
Koefoed K, Veland IR, Pedersen LB, Larsen LA, Christensen ST. Cilia and coordination of signaling networks during heart development. Organogenesis. 2014;10(1):108–25.
Basten SG, Giles RH. Functional aspects of primary cilia in signaling, cell cycle and tumorigenesis. Cilia. 2013;2(1):6.
Lienkamp S, Ganner A, Walz G. Inversin, Wnt signaling and primary cilia. Differentiation. 2012;83(2):S49–55.
Eggenschwiler JT, Anderson KV. Cilia and developmental signaling. Annu Rev Cell Dev Biol. 2007;23:345–73.
Anderson KV. Cilia and Hedgehog signaling in the mouse embryo. Harvey Lect. 2006;102:103–15.
Corbit KC, Shyer AE, Dowdle WE, Gaulden J, Singla V, Chen MH, Chuang PT, Reiter JF. Kif3a constrains beta-catenin-dependent Wnt signalling through dual ciliary and non-ciliary mechanisms. Nat Cell Biol. 2008;10(1):70–6.
Seeger-Nukpezah T, Little JL, Serzhanova V, Golemis EA. Cilia and cilia-associated proteins in cancer. Drug Discov Today Dis Mech. 2013;10(3–4):e135–42.
Yuan K, Frolova N, Xie Y, Wang D, Cook L, Kwon YJ, Steg AD, Serra R, Frost AR. Primary cilia are decreased in breast cancer: analysis of a collection of human breast cancer cell lines and tissues. J Histochem Cytochem. 2010;58(10):857–70.
Luu VD, Boysen G, Struckmann K, Casagrande S, von Teichman A, Wild PJ, Sulser T, Schraml P, Moch H. Loss of VHL and hypoxia provokes PAX2 up-regulation in clear cell renal cell carcinoma. Clin Cancer Res. 2009;15(10):3297–304.
Schraml P, Frew IJ, Thoma CR, Boysen G, Struckmann K, Krek W, Moch H. Sporadic clear cell renal cell carcinoma but not the papillary type is characterized by severely reduced frequency of primary cilia. Mod Pathol. 2009;22(1):31–6.
Kim J, Dabiri S, Seeley ES. Primary cilium depletion typifies cutaneous melanoma in situ and malignant melanoma. PLoS One. 2011;6(11):e27410.
Seeley ES, Carriere C, Goetze T, Longnecker DS, Korc M. Pancreatic cancer and precursor pancreatic intraepithelial neoplasia lesions are devoid of primary cilia. Cancer Res. 2009;69(2):422–30.
Gradilone SA, Radtke BN, Bogert PS, Huang BQ, Gajdos GB, LaRusso NF. HDAC6 inhibition restores ciliary expression and decreases tumor growth. Cancer Res. 2013;73(7):2259–70.
Hassounah NB, Nagle R, Saboda K, Roe DJ, Dalkin BL, McDermott KM. Primary cilia are lost in preinvasive and invasive prostate cancer. PLoS One. 2013;8(7):e68521.
Basten SG, Willekers S, Vermaat JS, Slaats GG, Voest EE, van Diest PJ, Giles RH. Reduced cilia frequencies in human renal cell carcinomas versus neighboring parenchymal tissue. Cilia. 2013;2(1):2.
Pan J, Wang Q, Snell WJ. An aurora kinase is essential for flagellar disassembly in Chlamydomonas. Dev Cell. 2004;6(3):445–51.
Pugacheva EN, Jablonski SA, Hartman TR, Henske EP, Golemis EA. HEF1-dependent Aurora A activation induces disassembly of the primary cilium. Cell. 2007;129(7):1351–63.
Plotnikova OV, Pugacheva EN, Golemis EA. Primary cilia and the cell cycle. Methods Cell Biol. 2009;94:137–60.
Kim S, Zaghloul NA, Bubenshchikova E, Oh EC, Rankin S, Katsanis N, Obara T, Tsiokas L. Nde1-mediated inhibition of ciliogenesis affects cell cycle re-entry. Nat Cell Biol. 2011;13(4):351–60.
Li A, Saito M, Chuang JZ, Tseng YY, Dedesma C, Tomizawa K, Kaitsuka T, Sung CH. Ciliary transition zone activation of phosphorylated Tctex-1 controls ciliary resorption, S-phase entry and fate of neural progenitors. Nat Cell Biol. 2011;13(4):402–11.
Huangfu D, Liu A, Rakeman AS, Murcia NS, Niswander L, Anderson KV. Hedgehog signalling in the mouse requires intraflagellar transport proteins. Nature. 2003;426(6962):83–7.
Mukhopadhyay S, Wen X, Ratti N, Loktev A, Rangell L, Scales SJ, Jackson PK. The ciliary G-protein-coupled receptor Gpr161 negatively regulates the Sonic hedgehog pathway via cAMP signaling. Cell. 2013;152(1–2):210–23.
Goetz SC, Anderson KV. The primary cilium: a signalling centre during vertebrate development. Nat Rev Genet. 2010;11(5):331–44.
Rohatgi R, Milenkovic L, Scott MP. Patched1 regulates hedgehog signaling at the primary cilium. Science. 2007;317(5836):372–6.
Mukhopadhyay S, Rohatgi R. G-protein-coupled receptors, Hedgehog signaling and primary cilia. Semin Cell Dev Biol. 2014;33:63–72.
Wong SY, Seol AD, So PL, Ermilov AN, Bichakjian CK, Epstein EH Jr, Dlugosz AA, Reiter JF. Primary cilia can both mediate and suppress Hedgehog pathway-dependent tumorigenesis. Nat Med. 2009;15(9):1055–61.
Sarkar FH, Li Y, Wang Z, Kong D. The role of nutraceuticals in the regulation of Wnt and Hedgehog signaling in cancer. Cancer Metastasis Rev. 2010;29(3):383–94.
Han YG, Kim HJ, Dlugosz AA, Ellison DW, Gilbertson RJ, Alvarez-Buylla A. Dual and opposing roles of primary cilia in medulloblastoma development. Nat Med. 2009;15(9):1062–5.
Wallingford JB, Mitchell B. Strange as it may seem: the many links between Wnt signaling, planar cell polarity, and cilia. Genes Dev. 2011;25(3):201–13.
Gerdes JM, Liu Y, Zaghloul NA, Leitch CC, Lawson SS, Kato M, Beachy PA, Beales PL, DeMartino GN, Fisher S, et al. Disruption of the basal body compromises proteasomal function and perturbs intracellular Wnt response. Nat Genet. 2007;39(11):1350–60.
Ocbina PJ, Tuson M, Anderson KV. Primary cilia are not required for normal canonical Wnt signaling in the mouse embryo. PLoS One. 2009;4(8):e6839.
Otto EA, Schermer B, Obara T, O’Toole JF, Hiller KS, Mueller AM, Ruf RG, Hoefele J, Beekmann F, Landau D, et al. Mutations in INVS encoding inversin cause nephronophthisis type 2, linking renal cystic disease to the function of primary cilia and left-right axis determination. Nat Genet. 2003;34(4):413–20.
Simons M, Gloy J, Ganner A, Bullerkotte A, Bashkurov M, Kronig C, Schermer B, Benzing T, Cabello OA, Jenny A, et al. Inversin, the gene product mutated in nephronophthisis type II, functions as a molecular switch between Wnt signaling pathways. Nat Genet. 2005;37(5):537–43.
Saadi-Kheddouci S, Berrebi D, Romagnolo B, Cluzeaud F, Peuchmaur M, Kahn A, Vandewalle A, Perret C. Early development of polycystic kidney disease in transgenic mice expressing an activated mutant of the beta-catenin gene. Oncogene. 2001;20(42):5972–81.
Pazour GJ, Dickert BL, Vucica Y, Seeley ES, Rosenbaum JL, Witman GB, Cole DG. Chlamydomonas IFT88 and its mouse homologue, polycystic kidney disease gene tg737, are required for assembly of cilia and flagella. J Cell Biol. 2000;151(3):709–18.
Yokoyama T. Renal cystic diseases as a ciliopathy. Nihon Rinsho. 2011;69(8):1495–503.
Dell KM. The role of cilia in the pathogenesis of cystic kidney disease. Curr Opin Pediatr. 2015;27(2):212–8.
Ross AJ, May-Simera H, Eichers ER, Kai M, Hill J, Jagger DJ, Leitch CC, Chapple JP, Munro PM, Fisher S, et al. Disruption of Bardet-Biedl syndrome ciliary proteins perturbs planar cell polarity in vertebrates. Nat Genet. 2005;37(10):1135–40.
Ferrante MI, Romio L, Castro S, Collins JE, Goulding DA, Stemple DL, Woolf AS, Wilson SW. Convergent extension movements and ciliary function are mediated by ofd1, a zebrafish orthologue of the human oral-facial-digital type 1 syndrome gene. Hum Mol Genet. 2009;18(2):289–303.
He X. Cilia put a brake on Wnt signalling. Nat Cell Biol. 2008;10(1):11–3.
Lancaster MA, Louie CM, Silhavy JL, Sintasath L, Decambre M, Nigam SK, Willert K, Gleeson JG. Impaired Wnt-beta-catenin signaling disrupts adult renal homeostasis and leads to cystic kidney ciliopathy. Nat Med. 2009;15(9):1046–54.
Liu B, Chen S, Cheng D, Jing W, Helms JA. Primary cilia integrate hedgehog and Wnt signaling during tooth development. J Dent Res. 2014;93(5):475–82.
Clement CA, Ajbro KD, Koefoed K, Vestergaard ML, Veland IR, Henriques de Jesus MP, Pedersen LB, Benmerah A, Andersen CY, Larsen LA, et al. TGF-beta signaling is associated with endocytosis at the pocket region of the primary cilium. Cell Rep. 2013;3(6):1806–14.
Habbig S, Bartram MP, Muller RU, Schwarz R, Andriopoulos N, Chen S, Sagmuller JG, Hoehne M, Burst V, Liebau MC, et al. NPHP4, a cilia-associated protein, negatively regulates the Hippo pathway. J Cell Biol. 2011;193(4):633–42.
Leitch CC, Lodh S, Prieto-Echague V, Badano JL, Zaghloul NA. Basal body proteins regulate Notch signaling through endosomal trafficking. J Cell Sci. 2014;127(Pt 11):2407–19.
Yabut O, Pleasure SJ, Yoon K. A Notch above Sonic Hedgehog. Dev Cell. 2015;33(4):371–2.
Wood CR, Huang K, Diener DR, Rosenbaum JL. The cilium secretes bioactive ectosomes. Curr Biol. 2013;23(10):906–11.
Avasthi P, Marshall W. Ciliary secretion: switching the cellular antenna to ‘transmit’. Curr Biol. 2013;23(11):R471–3.
Cao M, Ning J, Hernandez-Lara CI, Belzile O, Wang Q, Dutcher SK, Liu Y, Snell WJ. Uni-directional ciliary membrane protein trafficking by a cytoplasmic retrograde IFT motor and ciliary ectosome shedding. Elife. 2015;4:e05242.
Pietras K, Ostman A. Hallmarks of cancer: interactions with the tumor stroma. Exp Cell Res. 2010;316(8):1324–31.
Saeter T, Bogaard M, Vlatkovic L, Waaler G, Servoll E, Nesland JM, Axcrona K, Axcrona U. The relationship between perineural invasion, tumor grade, reactive stroma and prostate cancer-specific mortality: A clinicopathologic study on a population-based cohort. Prostate. 2015;76(2):207–14.
Moffitt RA, Marayati R, Flate EL, Volmar KE, Loeza SG, Hoadley KA, Rashid NU, Williams LA, Eaton SC, Chung AH, et al. Virtual microdissection identifies distinct tumor- and stroma-specific subtypes of pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma. Nat Genet. 2015;47(10):1168–78.
Yoshimura T, Liu M, Chen X, Li L, Wang JM. Crosstalk between tumor cells and macrophages in stroma renders tumor cells as the primary source of MCP-1/CCL2 in Lewis lung carcinoma. Front Immunol. 2015;6:332.
Dittmer J, Leyh B. The impact of tumor stroma on drug response in breast cancer. Semin Cancer Biol. 2015;31:3–15.
Kim H, Verhaak RG. Transcriptional mimicry by tumor-associated stroma. Nat Genet. 2015;47(4):307–9.
Choi AM, Ryter SW, Levine B. Autophagy in human health and disease. N Engl J Med. 2013;368(7):651–62.
Tang Z, Lin MG, Stowe TR, Chen S, Zhu M, Stearns T, Franco B, Zhong Q. Autophagy promotes primary ciliogenesis by removing OFD1 from centriolar satellites. Nature. 2013;502(7470):254–7.
Wrighton KH. Cytoskeleton: autophagy and ciliogenesis come together. Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol. 2013;14(11):687.
Pampliega O, Orhon I, Patel B, Sridhar S, Diaz-Carretero A, Beau I, Codogno P, Satir BH, Satir P, Cuervo AM. Functional interaction between autophagy and ciliogenesis. Nature. 2013;502(7470):194–200.
Tang Z, Zhu M, Zhong Q. Self-eating to remove cilia roadblock. Autophagy. 2014;10(2):379–81.
Singla V, Romaguera-Ros M, Garcia-Verdugo JM, Reiter JF. Ofd1, a human disease gene, regulates the length and distal structure of centrioles. Dev Cell. 2010;18(3):410–24.
Lopes CA, Prosser SL, Romio L, Hirst RA, O’Callaghan C, Woolf AS, Fry AM. Centriolar satellites are assembly points for proteins implicated in human ciliopathies, including oral-facial-digital syndrome 1. J Cell Sci. 2011;124(Pt 4):600–12.
Ferrante MI, Zullo A, Barra A, Bimonte S, Messaddeq N, Studer M, Dolle P, Franco B. Oral-facial-digital type I protein is required for primary cilia formation and left-right axis specification. Nat Genet. 2006;38(1):112–7.
Orhon I, Dupont N, Pampliega O, Cuervo AM, Codogno P. Autophagy and regulation of cilia function and assembly. Cell Death Differ. 2015;22(3):389–97.
Kim YC, Guan KL. mTOR: a pharmacologic target for autophagy regulation. J Clin Invest. 2015;125(1):25–32.
Wang S, Livingston MJ, Su Y, Dong Z. Reciprocal regulation of cilia and autophagy via the MTOR and proteasome pathways. Autophagy. 2015;11(4):607–16.
Petralia RS, Schwartz CM, Wang YX, Kawamoto EM, Mattson MP, Yao PJ. Sonic hedgehog promotes autophagy in hippocampal neurons. Biol Open. 2013;2(5):499–504.
Li H, Li J, Li Y, Singh P, Cao L, Xu LJ, Li D, Wang Y, Xie Z, Gui Y, et al. Sonic hedgehog promotes autophagy of vascular smooth muscle cells. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol. 2012;303(11):H1319–31.
Perera RM, Stoykova S, Nicolay BN, Ross KN, Fitamant J, Boukhali M, Lengrand J, Deshpande V, Selig MK, Ferrone CR, et al. Transcriptional control of autophagy-lysosome function drives pancreatic cancer metabolism. Nature. 2015;524(7565):361–5.
Aita VM, Liang XH, Murty VV, Pincus DL, Yu W, Cayanis E, Kalachikov S, Gilliam TC, Levine B. Cloning and genomic organization of beclin 1, a candidate tumor suppressor gene on chromosome 17q21. Genomics. 1999;59(1):59–65.
Liang XH, Jackson S, Seaman M, Brown K, Kempkes B, Hibshoosh H, Levine B. Induction of autophagy and inhibition of tumorigenesis by beclin 1. Nature. 1999;402(6762):672–6.
Takamura A, Komatsu M, Hara T, Sakamoto A, Kishi C, Waguri S, Eishi Y, Hino O, Tanaka K, Mizushima N. Autophagy-deficient mice develop multiple liver tumors. Genes Dev. 2011;25(8):795–800.
Karsli-Uzunbas G, Guo JY, Price S, Teng X, Laddha SV, Khor S, Kalaany NY, Jacks T, Chan CS, Rabinowitz JD, et al. Autophagy is required for glucose homeostasis and lung tumor maintenance. Cancer Discov. 2014;4(8):914–27.
White E. The role for autophagy in cancer. J Clin Invest. 2015;125(1):42–6.
White E. Q&A: targeting autophagy in cancer-a new therapeutic? Cancer Metab. 2014;2:14.
DiPaola RS, Dvorzhinski D, Thalasila A, Garikapaty V, Doram D, May M, Bray K, Mathew R, Beaudoin B, Karp C, et al. Therapeutic starvation and autophagy in prostate cancer: a new paradigm for targeting metabolism in cancer therapy. Prostate. 2008;68(16):1743–52.
Zhi X, Zhong Q. Autophagy in cancer. F1000Prime Rep. 2015;7:18.
Maes H, Rubio N, Garg AD, Agostinis P. Autophagy: shaping the tumor microenvironment and therapeutic response. Trends Mol Med. 2013;19(7):428–46.
Prabhu VV, Warfel NA, El-Deiry WS. CTGF-mediated autophagy-senescence transition in tumor stroma promotes anabolic tumor growth and metastasis. Cell Cycle. 2012;11(14):2592–3.
Zealley BJ, de Grey AD. Cancers co-opt cohabitants’ catabolism: autophagy and senescence in the tumor stroma. Cell Cycle. 2012;11(12):2230–1.
Martinez-Outschoorn UE, Whitaker-Menezes D, Pavlides S, Chiavarina B, Bonuccelli G, Casey T, Tsirigos A, Migneco G, Witkiewicz A, Balliet R, et al. The autophagic tumor stroma model of cancer or “battery-operated tumor growth”: a simple solution to the autophagy paradox. Cell Cycle. 2010;9(21):4297–306.
Salem AF, Whitaker-Menezes D, Lin Z, Martinez-Outschoorn UE, Tanowitz HB, Al-Zoubi MS, Howell A, Pestell RG, Sotgia F, Lisanti MP. Two-compartment tumor metabolism: autophagy in the tumor microenvironment and oxidative mitochondrial metabolism (OXPHOS) in cancer cells. Cell Cycle. 2012;11(13):2545–56.
Martinez-Outschoorn UE, Trimmer C, Lin Z, Whitaker-Menezes D, Chiavarina B, Zhou J, Wang C, Pavlides S, Martinez-Cantarin MP, Capozza F, et al. Autophagy in cancer associated fibroblasts promotes tumor cell survival: role of hypoxia, HIF1 induction and NFkappaB activation in the tumor stromal microenvironment. Cell Cycle. 2010;9(17):3515–33.
Du J, Teng RJ, Guan T, Eis A, Kaul S, Konduri GG, Shi Y. Role of autophagy in angiogenesis in aortic endothelial cells. Am J Physiol Cell Physiol. 2012;302(2):C383–91.
Kang R, Livesey KM, Zeh HJ 3rd, Lotze MT, Tang D. HMGB1 as an autophagy sensor in oxidative stress. Autophagy. 2011;7(8):904–6.
Kang R, Livesey KM, Zeh HJ, Loze MT, Tang D. HMGB1: a novel Beclin 1-binding protein active in autophagy. Autophagy. 2010;6(8):1209–11.
Ko YH, Lin Z, Flomenberg N, Pestell RG, Howell A, Sotgia F, Lisanti MP, Martinez-Outschoorn UE. Glutamine fuels a vicious cycle of autophagy in the tumor stroma and oxidative mitochondrial metabolism in epithelial cancer cells: implications for preventing chemotherapy resistance. Cancer Biol Ther. 2011;12(12):1085–97.
Martinez-Outschoorn UE, Whitaker-Menezes D, Lin Z, Flomenberg N, Howell A, Pestell RG, Lisanti MP, Sotgia F. Cytokine production and inflammation drive autophagy in the tumor microenvironment: role of stromal caveolin-1 as a key regulator. Cell Cycle. 2011;10(11):1784–93.
Martinez-Outschoorn UE, Pavlides S, Howell A, Pestell RG, Tanowitz HB, Sotgia F, Lisanti MP. Stromal-epithelial metabolic coupling in cancer: integrating autophagy and metabolism in the tumor microenvironment. Int J Biochem Cell Biol. 2011;43(7):1045–51.
Martinez-Outschoorn UE, Lin Z, Trimmer C, Flomenberg N, Wang C, Pavlides S, Pestell RG, Howell A, Sotgia F, Lisanti MP. Cancer cells metabolically “fertilize” the tumor microenvironment with hydrogen peroxide, driving the Warburg effect: implications for PET imaging of human tumors. Cell Cycle. 2011;10(15):2504–20.
MC and QZ wrote the paper. Both authors read and approved the final manuscript.
We thank Yuan Xue (Stanford University) for reading the manuscript. The work was supported by grants to QZ from the Welch Foundation (I-1864), CPRIT (RP140320), the American Cancer Society Research Scholar Grant (RSG-11–274–01-CCG) and NIH R01 (CA133228), and AHA Postdoctoral Fellowship (16POST27090033) to MC.
Both the authors declare that they have no competing interests.